Academic Writing Support
Modality & Hedging
According to Barnard and Scampton (2006) "students [...] might be expected to understand and use a range of modal expressions – particularly those preparing to undertake academic study in tertiary institutions." Yes, I am quoting myself Yet, the discussion around modality and hedging is a very important part of academic writing and one that often does not get enough attention in your classes. |
Hang on - Moda what? Hedga what? For the sake of simplicity, lets call Modality and Hedging the same thing. We have all studied 'Modal verbs' in class right? But what is the point? Basically Hedging and Modality soften what we say. Look at this example.
|
Now - What do we use to accomplish this? Modal Auxillary Verbs - these are the ones everyone talks about. Depending on who you read, Palmer (1986) suggests that there are nine whilst Leech (2001) identifies 11 and Kennedy (2003) includes 13. Good luck - I am assuming that you know them already? Lexical modality - this form of modality is harder to define. Thoughtco [Link] says that it is "...the expression of modal meanings through nouns, adjectives, verbs, or adverbs used in a modal context." So now that that is clear.... Can we say why it is important? No? |
OK - so the Hong Kong Polytechnic (2012) writes that
So, can you see how the addition of modality and hedging makes your opinion 'less-argue-with-able.' In your academic writing, you do not have all the answers (yet) and that is OK. But showing your tutors you have read and included expert opinions makes them think that you are making an informed suggestion, based on the reading and research that you have done. This is where the points are! |
OK - Examples Modal Auxiliary Verbs
Lexical modality
The list is pretty endless TBH. Even conditionals are a form of modality if you think about it. |
Ok, lets try some real examples adapted from student work from a Business course.
Your turn Grab one of your assignments - copy and paste 10 sentences and modalise them here - it is the same place as the previous page so don't worry about your paragraph. Add information on how you modalised the sentence the same as above (Lexical or Auxiliary verb modality). Don't forget to add references too ["jkbdfvjbhfjanhbdfvjahdbhdf" (Scampton, 2019)] if you can. Check out 'Some other little tips' below too. |
What have we learnt?
|
Some other little tips Was just thinking about the redundancy comment above and it reminded me of when my tutor told me I was being redundant - really hurt my feelings. Here are some things that I have learnt from hard experience. I will not keep saying this stuff, but try to keep it in mind as you do your assignments?
|