Modality & Hedging

 

According to Barnard and Scampton (2006) "students [...] might be expected to understand and use a range of modal expressions – particularly those preparing to undertake academic study in tertiary institutions."

Yes, I am quoting myself wink

Yet, the discussion around modality and hedging is a very important part of academic writing and one that often does not get enough attention in your classes.

Hang on - Moda what? Hedga what?

For the sake of simplicity, lets call Modality and Hedging the same thing.

We have all studied 'Modal verbs' in class right? But what is the point? Basically Hedging and Modality soften what we say. Look at this example.

You are being childish Result => Argument
I think you might be being childish Result => Other person rethinks their life

Now - What do we use to accomplish this?

Modal Auxillary Verbs - these are the ones everyone talks about. Depending on who you read, Palmer (1986) suggests that there are nine whilst Leech (2001) identifies 11 and Kennedy (2003) includes 13. Good luck - I am assuming that you know them already?

Lexical modality - this form of modality is harder to define. Thoughtco [Link] says that it is "...the expression of modal meanings through nouns, adjectives, verbs, or adverbs used in a modal context."

So now that that is clear.... Can we say why it is important? No?

OK - so the Hong Kong Polytechnic (2012) writes that

When you discuss ideas or data in your written assignments, you should use cautious rather than assertive language. This means that you should avoid expressions such as:

clearly obviously
without a doubt
certainly
undoubtedly
definitely
there is no doubt that it is a fact that angry



You should also take care when using words like always, never, every and all.

The reason for this is that academic writing usually reports on research, and in your research area there may be information that you have not found, exceptions to the rules that you find, and the situation may change over time. Therefore you need to use cautious language to avoid the possibility of people saying that you are wrong. BE CAREFUL: in the academic world teachers are looking for their students' mistakes, and researchers are looking for each other's mistakes. Criticizing mistakes and correcting them is part of scientific method, and is therefore common, and is regarded by researchers as a good thing to do.

So, can you see how the addition of modality and hedging makes your opinion 'less-argue-with-able.' In your academic writing, you do not have all the answers (yet) and that is OK. But showing your tutors you have read and included expert opinions makes them think that you are making an informed suggestion, based on the reading and research that you have done. This is where the points are!

EnglishRules

OK - Examples

Modal Auxiliary Verbs

Will Would Can Could
May Should Must Might
Shall Used to Ought to Need to

Lexical modality

Examples of modal adjectives include.... Examples of modal lexical verbs include... Examples of modal adverbs include...
  • able
  • advisable
  • bound to
  • concerned
  • important
  • likely
  • necessary
  • possible
  • supposed to
  • vital
  • advise
  • believe
  • intend
  • propose
  • recommend
  • suggest
  • wish
  • arguably
  • probably
  • maybe
  • possibly
  • perhaps
  • surely

The list is pretty endless TBH. Even conditionals are a form of modality if you think about it.

Ok, lets try some real examples adapted from student work from a Business course.

Original work [Used with permission]
Analysis
An action plan is very important for businesses.

First, this needs to be referenced, the student is not an expert. Second - the student is talking like they know everything - in other words, the student is talking like an expert. There is no sense that it might not be important (or at least not very important) to some businesses - like small one person corner stores.This is very 'argue-with-able.'

Perhaps -

An action plan is usually very important for most businesses.

OR

An action plan is usually very important for medium to large businesses.

  • Usually - Lexical Modality
  • Most - Lexical Modality
  • Medium to Large - Lexical Modality


Secondly, companies waste resources when the goals are not clear.

This statement makes this necessarily true of all companies. Adding modality will increase the 'less-argue-with-ability' of this statement

Secondly, companies may waste resources if the goals are not clear

OR

Secondly, if organizational goals are not clearly defined, resources may be wasted.

  • May - Modal Aux. Verb
  • If - Zero conditional

Notice the change of the sentence structure too, always put the most important part of the 'what you are talking about' at the beginning of the sentence. Wow! Perhaps I should modalize that - it is usually better to put the topic of the sentence at the beginning. wink Check out Theme and Rheme coming soon.


In every business and company there are mistakes that occur.

Besides the redundancy of 'business' and 'company' (we know when you add extra words to make up the word count), how can the writer know this? Has the writer worked in every business and company? The writer is most likely right, but we don't do this in academic writing.

In many companies...

In most companies...

...there are often mistakes made....

...there may be mistakes made...

  • Many - Lexical Modality
  • Most - Lexical Modality
  • Often - Lexical Modality
  • May - Modal Aux Verb

Long term goals are the direction the owner wants for the company.

Same issue, the author has made a blanket statement and has not considered that there may be other options or reasons. The statement could be completely true - if so, make it a quote. But if it is not a quote, you need to allow for other possibilities and reduce the impact on the reader. This is academic writing.

Long term goals are often the direction the owner wants for the company.

OR

The direction the organisation owner wants usually informs the long term goals they set.

  • Often - Lexical Modality
  • Usually - Lexical Modality

Your turn big grin

Grab one of your assignments - copy and paste 10 sentences and modalise them here - it is the same place as the previous page so don't worry about your paragraph. Add information on how you modalised the sentence the same as above (Lexical or Auxiliary verb modality). Don't forget to add references too ["jkbdfvjbhfjanhbdfvjahdbhdf" (Scampton, 2019)] if you can. Check out 'Some other little tips' below too.

What have we learnt?

  • Modality and hedging soften what you are saying and make it 'less-argue-with-able'
  • Modality can be lexical and/or auxiliary verbs
  • Avoid redundancy and blanket statements

Some other little tips

Was just thinking about the redundancy comment above and it reminded me of when my tutor told me I was being redundant - really hurt my feelings. Here are some things that I have learnt from hard experience. I will not keep saying this stuff, but try to keep it in mind as you do your assignments?

  • Only include one main idea per sentence
  • Keep sentences short - 25 words max (ish)
  • Do not repeat yourself
  • Use non-redundant academic language like:
    • 'Because' and not 'Due to the fact that'
    • 'Used' and not 'Employed the use of'
    • 'Fundamentals' and not 'Basic fundamentals'
    • 'Eliminate' and not 'Completely eliminate'
    • 'Alternatives' and not 'Alternative choices'
    • 'Concisely' and not 'In as few words as possible'
  • Nominalise if you can
  • And get ya spelling roight....